Posted: August 27, 2010 in The Duffy Dombrowski Fight Club
Tags: , , , , , , ,

[tweetmeme source=”schrecktom”https://tomschreck.wordpress.com/]

Bookmark this on Delicious


To order a Duffy book, click on one of the covers to the left.

Tomorrow night, James Toney, a four division boxing champ fights Randy Couture, a former UFC champ in a caged MMA match.

It’s being billed as a test for boxing.

It isn’t.

It isn’t close.

First of all, I reject the notion that MMA is taking over for boxing.

I think MMA is an intensely popular sport of it’s own and it doesn’t need boxing to be compared to. It’s an apples and oranges thing.

I also reject the idea that boxing is dead. This year I judged fights in Yankee Stadium with 25k fans. I wish boxing wasn’t on PPV but the big fights (at an obnoxious $55) often approach a million buys or more. That’s not dead.

Worldwide boxing is huge, particularly in the Phillipines, the Latin countries and Germany. Boxing has nothing to worry about.

Back to tomorrow night’s fight and what it will tell us. Toney is 42 and Couture is 47. They are both too old to matter. It’s a side show and not a barometer. An interesting sideshow, perhaps but nothing more.

I think it’s amazing that both are competing at this level but it won’t tell us anything. I judged Toney once fighting for the heavyweight title and he’s remarkable even when overweight.

I’m not a fan of MMA but I do respect it and I know Couture was one of the best.

These two sports don’t need to be pitted against each other, they can stand on their own. It’s interesting when a boxer enters the octogan like it was interesting when Michael Jordan played baseball.

Please don’t make assumptions about either sport regardless of the results.

When it comes to judging (if we must) the power of the boxer in such environments let’s wait until the cash in MMA is worthy of drawing a prime top notch boxer. James Toney, Ray Mercer and Frans Botha aren’t that.

To be fair, a 47 year old Couture isn’t.

Let’s let boxing and MMA exist like football and baseball.

  1. Pasquale Palumbo says:

    I think boxing struggles in the US because there hasn’t been a compelling Heavyweight to draw interest in a very, very long time.

  2. D. B. Dean says:

    plus…the MMA guys are hotter…and all the grappeling is well…hotter…and then they are more cut and scrappy and have awesome tattoos. ANd hotter…makes me wanna get in there and wrestle too…

    – side note – the doc has GOT to cut back on my meds…

  3. Graham says:

    I don’t know why many people seem to think that if you’re good at one, you should be good at the other. Couture didn’t have much trouble with Toney, but Toney could probably have handled him in a boxing match. They’re two different sports with two different skill sets. Why can’t they co-exist?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s